diff --git a/src/pretix/plugins/paypal2/views.py b/src/pretix/plugins/paypal2/views.py
index 3bc450942c..26bad8b091 100644
--- a/src/pretix/plugins/paypal2/views.py
+++ b/src/pretix/plugins/paypal2/views.py
@@ -149,19 +149,27 @@ class XHRView(View):
         else:
             cart_total = get_cart_total(request)
             cart_payments = cart_session(request).get('payments', [])
-            for fee in get_fees(request.event, request, cart_total, None, cart_payments, get_cart(request)):
+            multi_use_cart_payments = [p for p in cart_payments if p.get('multi_use_supported')]
+            simulated_payments = multi_use_cart_payments + [{
+                'provider': 'paypal',
+                'multi_use_supported': False,
+                'min_value': None,
+                'max_value': None,
+                'info_data': {},
+            }]
+
+            for fee in get_fees(request.event, request, cart_total, None, simulated_payments, get_cart(request)):
                 cart_total += fee.value
 
             total_remaining = cart_total
-            for p in cart_session(request).get('payments', []):
-                if p['provider'] != 'paypal':
-                    if p.get('min_value') and total_remaining < Decimal(p['min_value']):
-                        continue
+            for p in multi_use_cart_payments:
+                if p.get('min_value') and total_remaining < Decimal(p['min_value']):
+                    continue
 
-                    to_pay = total_remaining
-                    if p.get('max_value') and to_pay > Decimal(p['max_value']):
-                        to_pay = min(to_pay, Decimal(p['max_value']))
-                    total_remaining -= to_pay
+                to_pay = total_remaining
+                if p.get('max_value') and to_pay > Decimal(p['max_value']):
+                    to_pay = min(to_pay, Decimal(p['max_value']))
+                total_remaining -= to_pay
 
             cart_total = total_remaining